ManaNation.com is your

Magic the Gathering

destination for articles, podcasts, news and more!
Listen in to Judgecast, an audio podcast about the rules and for judges.

Constructed

Off the Beaten Path — We’re Off! Zendikar and Philadelphia 5k

Hello, friends, and wel­come to the first install­ment of ‘Off the Beaten Path.’ I’m Sam Fee­ley, for­merly known on the site as Sammy Time. Long-time Man­a­Na­tion cit­i­zens will rec­og­nize me from my old ‘Trial and Error’ series, where I exam­ined any­thing and every­thing tour­na­ment play­ers will encounter on their voy­ages to the Pro Tour. Well, I’m back, but ‘Trial and Error’ isn’t. Each week at ‘Off the Beaten Path’ I will peruse the var­i­ous Magic sites for tournament-worthy decks that are, as the title sug­gests, off the beaten path. These are what we some­times call call “metagame calls” — decks that are designed to han­dle a spe­cific sam­ple of pop­u­lar decks. I’ll be look­ing mostly at stan­dard, but where appro­pri­ate, I’ll exam­ine extended, block, and legacy as well. If you have a deck you want me to take for a ride and see if it can make it at a tour­na­ment, feel free to email me at samuraientertainment@gmail.com, and maybe you’ll see your name in these lights.

Now that we’ve got the for­mal­i­ties out of the way, let’s get started by look­ing at the results from the Star City Games 5K in Philadel­phia this past week­end. With the absence of Cryp­tic Com­mand and Vivid lands, I (among many) fig­ured this new Stan­dard would be a for­mat dom­i­nated by aggro, specif­i­cally Jund and Vam­pires. After look­ing at the top 16 lists, here are the num­bers we’re faced with:

Basic Arche­type: 13, aggro, 1 midrange, 2 con­trol
Col­ors: 15 with­out blue, 1 with blue

Okay, so far it’s look­ing just as we expected. Blue con­trol had its hey­day for long enough, now let’s let the other col­ors and arche­types shine, eh? Let’s dive in further.

Spe­cific Arche­type (accord­ing to SCG): 6 Jund Aggro, 3 Vam­pires, 2 Naya Lotus Angel, 1 Naya Aggro, 1 Lumi­narch Planeswalker Con­trol, 1 Boros Bush­whacker, 1 Mono-White Con­trol, 1 Red Deck Wins

Ten out of six­teen decks def­i­nitely don’t look out of place — Jund, Vam­pires, and Red Deck. “Boros Bush­whacker”, though silly-sounding, is just a super-fast red-white wee­nie deck (designed and cham­pi­oned by my fel­low Man­a­Na­tion writer Kelly Reid.) It’s a wel­come throw­back to a cou­ple of years ago and the days of Boros Deck Wins. Naya Aggro is just what it sounds like. But what the hell are “Naya Lotus Angel” and “Lumi­narch Planeswalker Con­trol”? And fur­ther­more, shouldn’t Mono-White Con­trol wait its turn until extended sea­son, where it has access to the stu­pid­ity that is Mar­tyr of Sands? Let’s have a look at those three.

Naya Lotus Angel
http://mtgurl.com/a5wc

This is the one midrange deck men­tioned above. Two dif­fer­ent ver­sions of this spe­cific arche­type made the top 16: this and a more aggro ver­sion piloted by Mike Innace. Innace’s ren­di­tion includes a Ranger of Eos suite and a much lower curve. But what catches my eye in both lists is Blood­braid Elf. Not that it’s there (of course it should be there), but what’s there below CMC 4. I want you to look at these decks side-by-side with any Jund deck that runs Blood­braid Elf. You’ll notice that while the inclu­sion of Blood­braid Elf in Theringer and Innace’s decks may seem second-nature, there aren’t as many threats to cas­cade into pre-board as in Jund (see Mael­strom Pulse, Blight­ning, et al). Again, in no way am I sug­gest­ing Blood­braid Elf should not be in this deck. There are plenty of tasty good­ies to flip into such as Naya Charm and Light­ning Bolt. It’s just that when you look at what the Elf gets to dig up in Jund, it’s no won­der six of the top six­teen decks were Jund — and five of them came before the first Naya deck.

Mono-White Con­trol
http://mtgurl.com/VxnR

As I said, you would think Eme­ria, the Sky Ruin’s first splash would be in Extended, where Mar­tyr of Sands is legal. Well, the party’s started already. You won’t find any absurd amounts of life gain here, but you will find board sweep­ers, spot removal, and a cou­ple of sexy smack­downs in Banes­layer Angel and Iona. While I’m still on the fence in regards to Iona being the next big fin­isher in con­trol decks, I def­i­nitely like her as a rean­i­ma­tion tar­get and an EDH gen­eral. Can you imag­ine how bad Iona would screw your oppo­nent in a one-on-one game of EDH? Espe­cially against Ben McDole’s Maga deck. Ouch. In the mean­time, Iona isn’t going to win me over as long as there are decks that will reli­ably get there by the time she can hit the table.

Lumi­narch Planeswalker Con­trol
http://mtgurl.com/2U3f

My ini­tial thought to abuse Lumi­narch Ascen­sion was a Bant deck with Sleep, Tan­gle­sap, Fog, Safe Pas­sage, and the like. But who needs Fog effects to trig­ger Lumi­narch Ascen­sion when you have spot removal after spot removal and seven board sweep­ers? Kudos to the big man Calosso Fuentes for com­ing up with this true Amer­i­can beauty. (It’s red-white-blue, get it? Groan.) Obvi­ously short on coun­ter­spells in a for­mat lack­ing Cryp­tic Com­mand and Bro­ken Ambi­tions, he’ll let the crea­tures resolve, blow them up, and counter the non­crea­tures with a well-timed Negate. Another inclu­sion that piques my inter­est is Rup­ture Spire. It’s no Reflect­ing Pool, but in this for­mat, it might as well be. Plus, bud­get play­ers will appre­ci­ate it hit­ting tour­na­ment tables as they won’t be pay­ing $100 a set to nab ‘em.

Don’t take the results from Philadel­phia for granted — this is a very young metagame and we still have FNM, Worlds, the new “States With­out Bor­ders” on Decem­ber 5, and two more Star City 5K’s in Nashville (Novem­ber 7) and St. Louis (Decem­ber 12) to help mold the scene by New Year’s. But no mat­ter what your metagame, never for­get the ele­phants, vam­pires, or Blood­braid Elves in the room, or they really will come back to bite you (espe­cially the vam­pires — you tend to feel those bites in the morning.)

Until next time, keep draw­ing the nuts.
Sam

Sam Fee­ley is a Timmy-Spike and PTQ semi-regular orig­i­nally from Con­cord, Mass­a­chu­setts. He enjoys Magic, sports, cook­ing, and writ­ing. He maintains two blogs, Samurai Entertainment on news, games, and nonsense; and Samurai Sports, about interior decorating. And by interior decorating he means sports.

Useful Author Links Last 4 posts

Comments

  1. My deck is bud­get! I have a few outs (Pla­nar Por­tal for Dupli­cant), but not many. I need to work on that…

    B.McDole | October 13, 2009, 9:52 am | #
  2. great piece look­ing for­ward to more.

    mtgxman | October 13, 2009, 11:00 pm | #

Post a comment

Please feel free to ask questions!

Please use your best grammar and spelling.

Note: We require polite discussions here, any uncivil behavior will be promptly removed.

Additional comments powered by BackType

ManaNation is video podcast about Magic the Gathering, it is copyright of its owner CoolStuffInc LLC and Patrick Jarrett. Magic the Gathering, and all related graphics are owned by Wizards of the Coast.